Call Now: (754) 333-0161Get a Free Quote
America's Movers — Moving Americans to What Moves Americans

Restaurants in Fire Island Pines, NY

Find the best restaurants in Fire Island Pines, NY. Browse local dining options — from casual eateries to fine dining, breakfast spots and more.

Restaurants 25–48 of 447 nearby

  1. Albatross

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    320 Bay Walk, Fire Island, 11770-2030

  2. Town Pizza

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

  3. Castaway

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

  4. Subway

    Sayville · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    286 Main Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

  5. Shabby Tabby

    Sayville · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    197 West Main Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

  6. La Tavola

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  7. Dunkin'

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

    165 Main Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

  8. Koi Sushi Lounge

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  9. Maguire's

    Ocean Beach · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

    1 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770

  10. The Wayward Kitchen and Cocktails

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  11. Sayville Pizza

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

    60

  12. Starbucks

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  13. Sayville Chocolatier

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

    6

  14. Aegean Cafe

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  15. Joelle

    Sayville · 4.9 miles straight-line from city center

  16. Downtown Burger at Five Points Cafe

    Sayville · 5.0 miles straight-line from city center

  17. Jade Garden

    Sayville · 5.0 miles straight-line from city center

  18. Umberto’s

    Sayville · 5.0 miles straight-line from city center

  19. Sal's Pizza

    Sayville · 5.1 miles straight-line from city center

  20. Redefine Meals

    Sayville · 5.1 miles straight-line from city center

    223 North Main Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

  21. Sayville Bait & Tackle

    Sayville · 5.1 miles straight-line from city center

    220 North Main Street

  22. Station Pub

    Sayville · 5.3 miles straight-line from city center

  23. Tony's Pizza

    Bayport · 5.6 miles straight-line from city center

    606 Montauk Highway, Bayport, NY, 11705

  24. Wendy's

    Oakdale · 5.7 miles straight-line from city center

    885 Montauk Highway, Oakdale, NY, 11769