Restaurants in Fire Island Pines, NY

Restaurants 1–24 of 447 nearby

1. Canteen

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

2. Pines Pizza

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

3. Pines Bistro & Martini Bar

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

4. Sip 'N Twirl

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

5. Marina

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

6. Marina Bar + Grill at the Blue Whale

   Cherry Grove · 0.1 miles straight-line from city center

7. Top of the Bay Bistro

   Cherry Grove · 1.2 miles straight-line from city center

   1 Dock Walk, Cherry Grove, NY, 11782

8. Island Breeze

   Cherry Grove · 1.2 miles straight-line from city center

   31 Bayview Walk, Cherry Grove, NY, 11782

9. Cherry Grove Pizza

   Fire Island · 1.2 miles straight-line from city center

   179 Ocean Walk, Fire Island, NY, 11782

10. Sand Castle on the Ocean

    Fire Island · 1.2 miles straight-line from city center

    106 Lewis Walk, Fire Island, NY, 11782

11. Casino Cafe

    Blue Point · 3.6 miles straight-line from city center

12. Flynn's Fire Island

    Fire Island · 3.7 miles straight-line from city center

    87 Bayview Avenue, Fire Island, NY, 11706

13. Schooner Inn

    Fire Island · 3.9 miles straight-line from city center

14. Lands End Caterers & Restaurant

    Sayville · 4.1 miles straight-line from city center

    80 Browns River Road, Sayville, NY, 11782

15. Cull House

    Sayville · 4.4 miles straight-line from city center

    75 Terry Street, Sayville, NY, 11782

16. Matthews

    Ocean Beach · 4.7 miles straight-line from city center

    935 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770

17. Bocce Beach

    Ocean Beach · 4.7 miles straight-line from city center

    926 Evergreen Walk, Fire Island, 11770

18. The Hideaway

    Ocean Beach · 4.7 miles straight-line from city center

    781 Evergreen Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770

19. Housers

    Ocean Beach · 4.7 miles straight-line from city center

20. The Island Mermaid

    Ocean Beach · 4.7 miles straight-line from city center

21. Beeches and Cream

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    Fire Island, 11770

22. Portly Villager

    Sayville · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    261 West Main Street, 11782

23. The Sandbar

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center

    470 Dehnhoff Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770

24. Rachel's Restaurant & Bakery

    Ocean Beach · 4.8 miles straight-line from city center