Call Now: (754) 333-0161Get a Free Quote
America's Movers — Moving Americans to What Moves Americans

Restaurants in Shelter Island, NY

Find the best restaurants in Shelter Island, NY. Browse local dining options — from casual eateries to fine dining, breakfast spots and more.

Restaurants 1–7 of 7

  1. 18 Bay

    Shelter Island · 0.2 miles straight-line from city center

    23 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964

  2. Bella Vita Pizza

    Shelter Island · 0.2 miles straight-line from city center

    53 North Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964

  3. Commander Cody's

    Shelter Island · 0.3 miles straight-line from city center

    41 Smith Street, Shelter Island, NY, 11964

  4. Vine Street Cafe

    Shelter Island · 0.7 miles straight-line from city center

    39 South Ferry Road, Shelter Island, NY, 11964

  5. The Shipwreck

    Shelter Island · 1.0 miles straight-line from city center

  6. Salt

    Shelter Island · 1.1 miles straight-line from city center

    63 South Menantic Road, Shelter Island, 11964

  7. Shelter Island Yacht Club

    Shelter Island · 1.5 miles straight-line from city center

    12 Chequit Avenue, Shelter Island, 11965